Black-only medical directory must open to all races after lawsuit

Black-only medical directory must open to all races after lawsuit

After a lawsuit from medical group Do No Harm, a Philadelphia-based directory of Black physicians is now open to all races.

The directory entitled “Black Doctors Directory” also changed its name to the “Community Health and Wellness Directory” following the lawsuit, according to the accepted offer of judgment.

Chairman of Do No Harm Dr. Stanley Goldfarb said in a statement: “We are grateful that the directory is open to physicians of all races.”

Do No Harm is an organization of “physicians, nurses, medical students, patients, and policymakers focused on keeping identity politics out of medical education, research, and clinical practice,” according to its website.

“Do No Harm has long opposed ‘racial concordance,’ a thoroughly debunked theory that only breeds suspicion and prejudice,” Goldfarb said.

As stated by Do No Harm, racial concordance is the belief that patients are best treated by a doctor of the same race.

“When medical providers prioritize expertise and high-quality care, patients will see better health outcomes,” Goldfarb said.

According to the case’s accepted offer of judgment, the directory “shall only publicize” itself under its new name “or an equally raceneutral name” and is “equally open to physicians regardless of race.”

“When determining whether to add a physician to the directory, Defendants will consider any licensed physician in the greater Philadelphia area who demonstrates a commitment to treating patients and communities historically and currently underserved,” the judgment said.

“Defendants will determine whether a physician meets those criteria without inquiring about or considering the physician’s race,” the judgment said.

Those sued by Do No Harm include WURD Radio, Penn Medicine and the Consortium of DEI Health Educators.

When asked for comment, neither WURD, University of Pennsylvania media relations, nor the Consortium Dedicated to Health Equity Education responded.

WURD radio, an African-American owned talk radio station in Philadelphia, released a statement saying it is glad the litigation has ended and that it “remains committed to advancing health equity by making quality health-related information accessible to as many as possible.”

When reached, Do No Harm referred The Center Square to its previous reports related to racial concordance that “point to the discrimination” the idea encourages in the healthcare system.

In one report, Do No Harm wrote that racial concordance ”amounts to the return of segregation of medicine, sowing seeds of distrust between physicians and patients of different races.”

“That is a recipe for even worse health outcomes for members of every race – the exact opposite of what racial concordance’s proponents seek.

Given the lack of concrete evidence in favor of racially matched medical care, “it is irresponsible for medical organizations and political actors to push, in practice or policy, for racial concordance in medicine, with the attendant radical restructuring of healthcare along racial lines,” the report said.

Events

No events

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

WCO P&Z Aug 5.3

Key Stretch of Bell Road on Track for Thanksgiving Reopening, Committee Approves Additional Funds

ARTICLE SUMMARY Construction on Bell Road between 159th and 151st Streets is scheduled to have all lanes open by Thanksgiving, officials announced as the Public Works & Transportation Committee approved a...
WCO LEG 8.5.2

Will County Leglislative Committee Opposes Federal Push for Heavier, Longer Trucks

ARTICLE SUMMARY: The Will County Board's Legislative Committee unanimously passed a resolution opposing any federal legislation that would increase the size and weight limits for commercial trucks on national roadways. Will...
WCO Public Safety.2

Will County Reports Progress in Opioid Fight, Highlights New FDA Labeling Rules

Article Summary: Will County is seeing a reduction in opioid overdose deaths and is expanding access to the reversal drug Narcan, health officials reported. The department also drew attention to...
WCO Cap Imp 8.5.4

In-House Staff Completes Major Renovations at Will County Adult Detention Facility

ARTICLE SUMMARY: Maintenance staff at the Will County Adult Detention Facility recently completed extensive renovations in-house, including a new control center and the full restoration of a 48-cell housing unit, saving...
Land use 8.5.25

Will County Advances Truck Repair Facility Plan on Manhattan Road Despite Resident Objections

Article Summary: A proposal to rezone nearly 14 acres on Manhattan Road for a truck repair facility advanced after receiving a recommendation for approval from the Will County Land Use...
WCO P&Z 8.12.1

PZC Grants Variance for Oversized Garage in Joliet Township, Reversing Staff Recommendation

Article Summary: The Will County Planning and Zoning Commission unanimously approved a variance for a Joliet Township homeowner to build a garage addition that exceeds the county's size limits. The...
WCO P&Z Aug 5.5

Will County Public Works Committee Approves Over $1.1 Million in New Agreements for 80th Avenue Project

ARTICLE SUMMARY: The Will County Public Works & Transportation Committee authorized two agreements totaling over $1.1 million for the ongoing reconstruction and widening of 80th Avenue between 191st and 183rd Streets....
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Will County Board Legislative Committee for August 5, 2025

The Will County Board’s Legislative Committee focused on shaping its advocacy efforts at both the state and federal levels during its August 5 meeting. The primary discussion centered on crafting...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Will County Board Capital Improvements & IT Committee for August 5, 2025

The future of several key county facilities dominated the Will County Capital Improvements & IT Committee meeting on Tuesday. A major topic of discussion was the ongoing buildout of the...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Will County Land Use & Development Committee for August 7, 2025

The Will County Land Use & Development Committee tackled two contentious zoning cases during its August 7 meeting, denying a special use permit for a landscaping business in a residential...

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Will County Planning and Zoning Commission for August 5, 2025

The Will County Planning and Zoning Commission backed two controversial projects at its August 5 meeting, unanimously approving a large-scale landscaping business on a residential lot in DuPage Township despite...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Will County Public Works & Transportation Committee for August 5, 2025

The Will County Public Works & Transportation Committee received a detailed presentation on "Our Way Forward 2050," a new 25-year long-range plan designed to guide the region's transportation infrastructure through...
Meeting-Briefs

Meeting Summary: Peotone School District 207-U for July 21, 2025

District Weighs Budget Cuts vs. More Debt: Peotone schools must create a state-mandated deficit reduction plan to address a recurring ~$2 million operating shortfall. The Board of Education is debating whether...
Beecher Graphic.1

Beecher Officially Adopts 1% Grocery Tax to Avert $202,000 Budget Hit

Article Summary: The Beecher Village Board unanimously passed an ordinance to establish a local 1% grocery tax, a proactive measure to prevent an estimated annual revenue loss of over $200,000...
Beecher Graphic.3

Hunter’s Chase Residents Confront Beecher Board Over Lennar Construction Issues

Article Summary: A group of frustrated residents from Beecher's Hunter's Chase subdivision attended the July 28 Village Board meeting to voice numerous complaints about Lennar's new home construction, citing early...