Black-only medical directory must open to all races after lawsuit

Black-only medical directory must open to all races after lawsuit

After a lawsuit from medical group Do No Harm, a Philadelphia-based directory of Black physicians is now open to all races.

The directory entitled “Black Doctors Directory” also changed its name to the “Community Health and Wellness Directory” following the lawsuit, according to the accepted offer of judgment.

Chairman of Do No Harm Dr. Stanley Goldfarb said in a statement: “We are grateful that the directory is open to physicians of all races.”

Do No Harm is an organization of “physicians, nurses, medical students, patients, and policymakers focused on keeping identity politics out of medical education, research, and clinical practice,” according to its website.

“Do No Harm has long opposed ‘racial concordance,’ a thoroughly debunked theory that only breeds suspicion and prejudice,” Goldfarb said.

As stated by Do No Harm, racial concordance is the belief that patients are best treated by a doctor of the same race.

“When medical providers prioritize expertise and high-quality care, patients will see better health outcomes,” Goldfarb said.

According to the case’s accepted offer of judgment, the directory “shall only publicize” itself under its new name “or an equally raceneutral name” and is “equally open to physicians regardless of race.”

“When determining whether to add a physician to the directory, Defendants will consider any licensed physician in the greater Philadelphia area who demonstrates a commitment to treating patients and communities historically and currently underserved,” the judgment said.

“Defendants will determine whether a physician meets those criteria without inquiring about or considering the physician’s race,” the judgment said.

Those sued by Do No Harm include WURD Radio, Penn Medicine and the Consortium of DEI Health Educators.

When asked for comment, neither WURD, University of Pennsylvania media relations, nor the Consortium Dedicated to Health Equity Education responded.

WURD radio, an African-American owned talk radio station in Philadelphia, released a statement saying it is glad the litigation has ended and that it “remains committed to advancing health equity by making quality health-related information accessible to as many as possible.”

When reached, Do No Harm referred The Center Square to its previous reports related to racial concordance that “point to the discrimination” the idea encourages in the healthcare system.

In one report, Do No Harm wrote that racial concordance ”amounts to the return of segregation of medicine, sowing seeds of distrust between physicians and patients of different races.”

“That is a recipe for even worse health outcomes for members of every race – the exact opposite of what racial concordance’s proponents seek.

Given the lack of concrete evidence in favor of racially matched medical care, “it is irresponsible for medical organizations and political actors to push, in practice or policy, for racial concordance in medicine, with the attendant radical restructuring of healthcare along racial lines,” the report said.

Events

No events

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Meeting-Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Prairie State College Board of Trustees for March 25, 2025

The Prairie State College (PSC) Board of Trustees meeting on March 25, 2025, was highlighted by a detailed presentation showcasing significant growth and high achievement in the college's Allied Health...
Meeting Briefs

Will County Public Health & Safety Committee July 3 Meeting Briefs

Grain Dust Complaint Prompts Investigation: Will County resident Tracy Henning of unincorporated Peotone addressed the committee about health problems she attributes to grain dust from a neighboring facility. Henning, who...
prairie state college graphic.3

Prairie State College Board Accepts Positive FY2024 Financial Audit

Article Summary: The Prairie State College Board of Trustees unanimously accepted the audited financial statements for fiscal year 2024, signaling a clean bill of financial health for the institution. A...
Will County Legislative Committee Meeting July 1, 2025

Will County Seeks Asian Carp Provision in Federal Legislative Agenda

Will County Board member Julie Berkowicz is pushing to add specific language addressing Asian carp invasion to the county's federal legislative agenda, citing the ongoing threat to local waterways as...
Will County Capital Improvements & IT Committee Meeting July 1, 2025

Will County’s Major Capital Projects Hit Key Milestones, VAC Buildout on “Aggressive Schedule”

Will County is making significant headway on several major capital improvement projects, with the new Veterans Assistance Commission (VAC) & Support Center in Joliet on an “aggressive schedule” for a...
Will County Legislative Committee Meeting July 1, 2025

State Legislative Session Update: Transit, Energy Bills Stall Despite Democratic Control

Illinois lawmakers failed to advance major transit funding and comprehensive energy legislation during the recently concluded spring session, leaving key issues unresolved despite Democratic supermajorities in both chambers, according to...
Will County Public Works & Transportation Committee Meeting July 1, 2025

County Board Approves 2026-2031 Transportation Plan Despite Project Opposition

Will County board members approved a contested five-year transportation improvement plan Tuesday after heated debate over a controversial Homer Glen road project that has drawn sustained community opposition. The Will...
Will County Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting July 1, 2025

Contentious I-3 Rezoning for DuPage Township Storage Yard Narrowly Advances

A proposal to rezone a 20-acre parcel in DuPage Township from agricultural to the county's most intensive industrial classification narrowly earned a recommendation for approval from the Will County Planning...
Meeting Briefs

Will County Legislative Committee July 1 Meeting Briefs

Federal Budget Impact: Will County could face significant funding challenges if federal budget reconciliation measures reduce Medicaid and SNAP benefits. The county health department and social services rely heavily on...
Will County Finance Committee Meeting July 1, 2025

County Moves Forward with $200.8 Million Bond Refinancing Plan

Will County Finance Committee members on July 1 approved moving forward with a comprehensive bond refinancing ordinance that could save taxpayers more than $716,000 over the life of the bonds...
Will County Public Works & Transportation Committee Meeting July 1, 2025

Access Will County Dial-a-Ride Program Sees Record Growth, Eyes Expansion

Will County's dial-a-ride transportation service for seniors and disabled residents reached record ridership levels while officials plan major expansion to cover all county townships. The Access Will County program served...
Will County Capital Improvements & IT Committee Meeting July 1, 2025

Will County to Launch New Public Meeting Agenda System in August Amidst Data Conversion Concerns

Will County is set to launch its new public meeting agenda and records software, Granicus “OneMeeting,” in August, but the transition will see over a decade of historical records converted...
Will County Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting July 1, 2025

Green Garden Township Poised for First Major Subdivision in Years After Rezoning

The Will County Planning and Zoning Commission has recommended a rezoning that could pave the way for the first major residential subdivision in Green Garden Township in nearly two decades....
Will County Finance Committee Meeting July 1, 2025

County RNG Facility Shows Strong Performance Despite Solar Challenges

Will County's Renewable Natural Gas facility is exceeding production targets while officials explore options to reduce substantial electricity costs that currently impact profitability. Project manager Greg Komperda told Finance Committee...
Meeting Briefs

PZC Briefs: Solar Farm in Crete, Post-Fire Permit for Troy Business, and More

The Will County Planning and Zoning Commission handled several other cases during its July 1 meeting, including a new solar farm, a temporary permit for a fire-damaged business, and routine...