Critics question unions after $1B in political spending

Critics question unions after $1B in political spending

Spread the love

Following a report by Defending Education revealing that the nation’s largest teachers unions spent more than $1 billion on political activities, education experts are questioning whether the unions’ heavy political spending has produced any meaningful improvement in student outcomes.

The report by the non-profit Defending Education found that the American Federation of Teachers and the National Education Association together directed approximately $669 million toward federal political activity and another $336 million toward state and local political spending since 2015.

The totals include member dues, Political Action Committee contributions and Committee on Political Education funds, which are collected separately from standard union membership dues and fees.

In an interview with The Center Square, Lance Izumi, senior director of the Center for Education at the Pacific Research Institute, said the report’s findings continue to raise questions about the priorities of teachers’ unions and the impact of their political spending.

“Teacher unions are an ATM machine for the Democratic Party,” Izumi said.

Izumi argued that if union-backed political spending is intended to improve public education through increased funding, measurable gains should appear in student achievement and proficiency levels.

“If the unions say that we’re funding these candidates because we’re going to get more funding, and that’s going to somehow make the difference to the children, then we should be able to see that when it comes to student performance indicators,” Izumi added.

Izumi also referenced results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress, often called the Nation’s Report Card.

On the NAEP eighth-grade mathematics assessment, 27% of California eighth graders scored at or above proficiency in 2015. By 2024, that figure had fallen to 25%, according to NAEP.

On the eighth-grade reading assessment, 28% of California students scored at or above the proficient level in both 2015 and 2024, showing no improvement over the decade.

“Despite the fact that the union spent $106 million in political spending over that ten-year period by the CTA, that didn’t move the needle at all,” Izumi said. “So the system didn’t get any better for the children when it came to their achievement. It simply made the unions more powerful and made them kingmakers.”

Izumi also pointed specifically to spending by the California Teachers Association, which is a large and influential teachers’ union.

According to data from Public Union Facts, the California Teachers Association has spent more than $236 million on political activity. Federal contribution records cited in the report showed approximately 98.4% of political donations went to Democratic candidates and organizations, compared to 1.6% for Republicans.

The Defending Education report focused on state and local political spending, where the report highlights that unions increasingly fund advocacy organizations and issue campaigns beyond traditional labor concerns.

According to the report, at the state and local level alone, teachers’ unions spent more than $135.8 million to support opposition to school choice initiatives.

“Teachers unions are, in essence, running a quasi-monopoly,” Cliff Smith, government affairs director at North American Values Institute, told The Center Square. “Competition is the one thing monopolies can’t stand, since it reveals their deficiencies that they’d rather not answer for.”

The Center Square reached out to the Florida Education Association for comment but FEA Press Secretary Autumn Bell wrote in a state that no representative was available to discuss the issue.

The Center Square also reached out to the CTA, NEA and AFT unions but did not receive a response.

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Fugitive accused in $547 million Medicare fraud scheme captured

Fugitive accused in $547 million Medicare fraud scheme captured

By Nolan MckendryThe Center Square A man accused of orchestrating a $547 million Medicare fraud scheme through diagnostic laboratories in Louisiana and other states has been captured overseas and returned...
Ongoing border enforcement: Revocation of citizenship of convicted criminals

Ongoing border enforcement: Revocation of citizenship of convicted criminals

By Bethany BlankleyThe Center Square The Trump administration continues its multifaceted approach to border security and national security, including its concerted effort to denaturalize citizenship of convicted criminals. The administration...
Minnesota wildfires prompt burning restrictions as air quality improves

Minnesota wildfires prompt burning restrictions as air quality improves

By Elyse ApelThe Center Square More than a dozen wildfires in northern Minnesota are adding to ongoing air quality concerns throughout the U.S., which have been primarily fueled by Canadian...
Poll: Americans views of socialism little changed despite recent elections

Poll: Americans views of socialism little changed despite recent elections

By Dan McCalebThe Center Square Despite the 2025 elections of self-proclaimed socialists Zohran Mamdani and Katie Wilson as mayors of New York City and Seattle, respectively, the number of American...
Malliotakis: Commie Caucus is coming to Congress

Malliotakis: Commie Caucus is coming to Congress

By Christen SmithThe Center Square A growing tide of democratic Socialist candidates spurred comments on Tuesday from U.S. Rep. Nicole Malliotakis about the “rude awakening” of communism that lies ahead...
Texas Republicans chastise Mexican official’s 'audacious' border security claims

Texas Republicans chastise Mexican official’s ‘audacious’ border security claims

By Bethany BlankleyThe Center Square Texas Republicans are criticizing a Mexican official in response to a letter he sent about U.S. border security. In an open letter to Mexican Senator...
Feds freeze $1B to California, Minnesota Medicaid

Feds freeze $1B to California, Minnesota Medicaid

By Andrew RiceThe Center Square The Trump administration is pausing more than $1 billion in Medicaid payments to California and Minnesota, U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy...
Arrangements, services in place for Graham

Arrangements, services in place for Graham

By Alan WootenThe Center Square In a service expected to bring together many foreign leaders touched through his policy work on behalf of the United States, the late U.S. Sen....
Push increased for Dalilah’s Law to get a floor vote

Push increased for Dalilah’s Law to get a floor vote

By Alan WootenThe Center Square More than four months later, federal legislation from a North Carolina congressman addressing nondomiciled commercial drivers remains stuck in the U.S. House of Representatives. A...
Texas suffers its first casualty in Iran war: female soldier from Carrollton

Texas suffers its first casualty in Iran war: female soldier from Carrollton

By Bethany BlankleyThe Center Square Texas has suffered its first casualty in the U.S.-Israel war against Iran: Army Pvt. Isabella Gonzales, 19, of Carrollton. She was killed in action on...
Illinois quick hits: Benton's replacement chosen; gas prices resume climb

Illinois quick hits: Benton’s replacement chosen; gas prices resume climb

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square Benton's replacement chosen Jessica Dixon Heitman was chosen unanimously to replace former state Rep. Harry Benton, D-Plainfield, in the 97th House...
Illinois diversity certifications lag despite partial computer fix

Illinois diversity certifications lag despite partial computer fix

By Jared Strong | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) -- State diversity leaders recently reported a large increase in the number of Illinois businesses that get better...
FBI: Suspect in federal building attack was anti-ICE 'extremist'

FBI: Suspect in federal building attack was anti-ICE ‘extremist’

By Chris WadeThe Center Square A man arrested by federal agents Monday for starting a large blaze outside a New York City immigration court was an "anti-government extremist" who told...
U.S. House to vote on government funding stopgap

U.S. House to vote on government funding stopgap

By Thérèse BoudreauxThe Center Square Republican lawmakers have teed up a Continuing Resolution that would extend government funding at current levels until Dec. 4, punting the government shutdown deadline by...
Trump vows retaliation for U.S. service members' deaths

Trump vows retaliation for U.S. service members’ deaths

By Sarah Roderick-FitchThe Center Square For a 10th consecutive night, the U.S. is carrying out strikes on Iran, targeting the Islamic Republic’s ability to attack commercial ships in the Strait...